Mini-open sinus tarsi approach with percutaneous screw fixation of displaced calcaneal fractures: A prospective study
2 Assistant Professor Department of Orthopaedics, Rd Gardi Medical College Ujjain (M.P.), India, Email: firstname.lastname@example.org
3 Professor, Department of Orthopaedics Rd Gardi Medical College Ujjain (M.P.), India
4 Assistant professor, Department of Orthopaedics Rd Gardi Medical College Ujjain (M.P), India
Received: 26-Aug-2022, Manuscript No. jotsrr-22-73048; Editor assigned: 28-Aug-2022, Pre QC No. jotsrr-22-73048 (PQ); Accepted Date: Sep 21, 2022 ; Reviewed: 11-Sep-2022 QC No. jotsrr-22-73048 (Q); Revised: 18-Sep-2022, Manuscript No. jotsrr-22-73048 (R); Published: 25-Sep-2022, DOI: 10.37532/1897-2276.2022.17 (8).72
This open-access article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (CC BY-NC) (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/), which permits reuse, distribution and reproduction of the article, provided that the original work is properly cited and the reuse is restricted to noncommercial purposes. For commercial reuse, contact email@example.com
Calcaneal fractures are the most common fractures of the foot in our body and represent 1-2% of all fractures. Among these fractures, >75% fractures are intra-articular fractures, which are frequently associated with prolonged disability if not treated. The goal of our study was to assess clinical and functional outcome and complications of Calcaneal fracture operated with k wire and screw fixation through sinus tarsi approach. ORIF of calcaneal fractures using an extended lateral approach results in soft tissue disruption and stiffness of subtalar joint.
A minimally invasive sinus tarsi approach used in calcaneal fractures for posterior facet of calcaneal exposure and percutaneous screw fixation of the calcaneal body through Sinus Tarsi Approach has been implemented. Methods: This study was conducted at Department of Orthopedics, RD Gardi Medical College Ujjain between Dec 2018 to Aug 2021 on 20 patients managed surgically by Mini-Open Sinus Tarsi Approach (18 Sanders type II and 2 type III). All patients both clinical and radiological evaluations. Results: The follow-up duration for all patients ranged from 12 to 24 months. The radiological evaluations show significant corrections of the Böhler angle, and Gissane angle from pre-operatively to 3 months post-operatively and the last follow-up.
However, there no significant differences in the variables between 3 months and the last follow-up postoperatively. Conclusion: Sinus tarsi approach provides good exposure to the talocalcaneal joint. ORIF of calcaneus fractures through sinus tarsi approach allows good exposure with low risk of complications. It’s less invasive method for treatment of calcaneal fractures. It permits good exposure of the fracture, and allows good reduction of articular surfaces. Most patients had good or excellent functional outcome results, through Sinus tarsi approach.
Calcaneal Fractures; open reduction and internal fixation (ORIF), Mini- Open; Sinus Tarsi Approach
Calcaneus fractures comprise 1%-2% of all fractures of the human body and 60% of all tarsal bones injuries . Calcaneal fractures are occur predominantly in young patients. Calcaneal fractures are typically High-energy axial traumas, such as fall from height or motor accidents, are the common causes for calcaneal fractures . Calcaneus fractures are 2 types: extra-articular and intra-articular. 60% -75% of calcaneal fractures are Displaced Intra-Articular Calcaneal fractures (DIACFs). DIACFs can cause hind foot deformities and if its persist for long term can cause pain and stiffness of joint . Anatomic reduction of the posterior facet of the subtalar joint is critical to successful outcomes, and efforts have been made to restore calcaneal geometry .Treatments options, such as percutaneous pins, k wire fixation, open reduction, primary fusion and total excision, have been used for displaced intraarticular Calcaneal fractures in the past. However, many surgeons have recommended open reduction and internal fixation with conventional plate via an extensible lateral L-shaped approach for displaced intraarticular Calcaneal fractures . However, several studies report high postoperative wound complications rate including wound dehiscence, flap necrosis, deep infection, hematoma, using extensible lateral L-shaped approach . Various techniques have been suggested for fixation, such as the use of a screw and plate for percutaneous, semiand mini open fixation. These techniques have not been evaluated for the quality of reduction and stability of internal fixation. Using smaller incision, sinus tarsi approach allows visualization of the articular reduction while limiting soft tissue dissection . The aim of our study was (a) to assess the quality of reduction, (b) to assess stability of fixation and (c) to evaluate clinical outcome (Table 1).
Table 1. Clinical Outcome According to AOFAS Hind foot Score.
|AOFAS Scale||Mean ± SD||Range|
|PAIN||34.7 ± 7.0||20 – 40|
|FUNCTION||43.6 ± 6.0||27 – 50|
|ALIGNMENT||8.4 ± 2.9||0-10|
|TOTAL||86.7 ± 15.9||57 – 100|
Material and Methods
This study was conducted at Department of Orthopaedics, RD Gardi Medical College Ujjain between Dec 2018 to Aug 2021 on 20 patients managed surgically by Mini-Open Sinus Tarsi Approach (18 Sanders type II and 2 type III).The mean age was 34 years (range 18 years to 54 years). 14/20 patients were male and 06/20 were female. 06 patients had fracture of left side, 12 had right side and 2 sustained bilateral fractures. The most common mechanism of injury was fall from height seen in 13 patients and 7 had road traffic accident. The mean follow up period was 16 months (range 12 months-24 months). Mean union time was 10 weeks (range 8 weeks-12 weeks).The fractures were evaluated by standard radiographic views- axial, lateral, Antero-Posterior (AP) view of the foot, and ankle-mortise views. The fractures were further evaluated by Computerized Tomographic (CT) scans. Sanders classification was used to classify the fractures based on a CT scan (Figure 1).
OBSERVATIONS AND ANALYSIS
Preoperative Bohler angle ranged from 7.10±23.19 degrees and postoperative 24.16±8.12 Preoperative Gissane angle ranged from 38.8-105 degrees and postoperative gissane angle 105-138 degree. The preoperative and postoperative calcaneal anatomical parameters were compared by the paired t-test .Comparisons were considered to be significant at P<0.05 (Figure 2-6).
Postoperatively Radiographs were taken to measure the Calcaneal anatomical parameters, including Böhler angle (6) and Gissane angle(7).The suction drain was removed 1 day postoperative day.
Sutures were removed at 14 days. Progressive weight bearing was allowed at 8 weeks postoperative and full weight bearing was permitted at 12 weeks. Using the Maryland foot scoring system (100 points), clinical assessment of patients . An overall result of excellent (90-100), good (80–89), fair (70-79), and poor (<69) was assigned to each fracture (Table 2).
Table 2. Postoperative Maryland foot score.
|Sanders type||Feet||Excellent (90–100)||Good (80–89)||Fair (70–79)||Poor (60–69)|
The surgery was done with the patient in a lateral decubitus position after administration of spinal anesthesia. Tourniquet was used in all cases after exsanguination. Approximately 5cm -7 cm long incision was made starting from 1 cm below the tip of lateral malleolus extending anteriorly in the line of the fourth metatarsal. Subcutaneous tissue was dissected.
Soft tissue care was taken to avoid injury of sural nerve. Sinus tarsi fat pad was mobilized, and the origin of extensor digitorum brevis was elevated sharply and reflected dorsally and distally along with an inferior attachment of the extensor retinaculum. The peroneal sheath was sharply dissected and tendons were retracted inferiorly. Subtalar joint was exposed by capsulotomy and the posterior facet of calcaneum was identified .
In pure tongue depression type fractures, the facet was elevated using the Essex Lopresti maneuver, while in thalamic depression fractures, a periosteal elevator was passed below the depressed fragment to elevate the posterior facet. Alternatively, a novel technique used in which multiple drill holes are made with 3.2 mm drill bit over tuberosity just below Tendo Achilles (TA) insertion and a vertical slit was created to pass a Kirschner wire (k-wire) for use as a joystick, and the depressed thalamic fragment was elevated under fluoroscopy guidance .Then the reduction was assessed in axial view.
If the medial wall was not reduced then a Schanz screw was passed from tuberosity anteriorly to exert valgus force and simultaneously a small bone spike was passed between the body and sustentaculum fragment and levered back to achieve reduction. We have found the Mixter forceps to be a useful tool in some cases which was passed medially to hook the sustentacular fragment and the fragment pulled laterally with a valgus force applied from the posteriorly placed Schanz pin. The reduction was held with a k-wire passed anteriorly from tuberosity toward the sustentaculum tali. Then the elevated facet fragment was temporarily fixed to a constant medial fragment with a 2 mm k-wire and the reduction was assessed under fluoroscopy. Another 1 mm k-wire was passed directed medially anteriorly, and cephalad to caudate, exiting medially through the anterior part of the sustentaculum. A 4 mm cannulated drill was passed over this wire and a cannulated screw of appropriate size was inserted over the wire. A “kickstand” screw is inserted to support the elevated facet. Two or three postero anterior screws were inserted to maintain the length of the calcaneus. Small 2.7 mm screws were used to fix anterolateral fragments when required. The reduction was assessed by passing a periosteal elevator in the subtalar space to feel for any incongruity or articular step. Further, the reduction was assessed visually and on fluoroscopy by obtaining axial, lateral, and Broden’s views. Wound washed and closure was done in layers. The posterior splint was applied. The dressing was mostly done on 5th day. Sutures were removed on 12th day-14th day and the splint was discontinued. Mobilization was initiated at the visit for suture removal. Radiographic evaluation was done monthly for the first three months and then at 6 months and 9 months. Partial weightbearing was initiated at 4 weeks-6 weeks and full weight-bearing from 8 weeks-10 weeks (Figure 7)
AOFAS (American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society) hindfoot score used for evaluation of function outcome . Results were graded excellent for >90 points, good for >80, fair for >70, and poor when ≤70.41. Range of motion (ROM) at the subtalar joint was assessed by comparing the injured foot to the contralateral side. Pain was assessed using a Visual Analog Scale (VAS), ranging from 0 (no pain) to 10 (maximum pain). A careful physical examination performed to identify any local sensitivity, such as scar irritation, sensory neurological deficit, and tenderness (Table 3). Statistical analysis All data were analyzed by SPSS 17.0 statistical software and expressed as mean ± standard deviation. The pre and postoperative calcaneal anatomical parameters were compared by the paired t test. Comparisons were considered significant when P<0.05 (Table 4).
Table 3. Preoperative and Postoperative
|BOHLER ANGLE||GISSANE ANGLE|
Table 4. Patients Dermography
|Age (mean) yrs||34|
|Mechanism of injury|
|Fall from height||13|
The treatment of calcaneal fractures is aimed at restoration of the posterior facet of the subtalar joint, restoration of the height of calcaneus (Bohler angle), reduction of the width of calcaneum, decompression of subfibular space available for peroneal tendons, realignment of tuberosity into a valgus position, and reduction of the calacaneo-cuboid joint if fractured. pursued in patients with a joint step-off of more than 2 mm or fracture gap of more than 3 mm.
Various alternative open approaches have been developed in treating DIACFs, including extensile lateral approach, medial approach, combined lateral and medial approach, limited posterolateral approach, and sinus tarsi approach .Open reduction and internal fixation is currently considered the gold standard in the surgical treatment of displaced intra-articular fractures, Several surgical techniques have been described of which the extended lateral approach most frequently applied. Advantages of the extensile lateral approach include wide exposure of the subtalar joint allowing more accurate reduction of the facet fragments, ability to decompress the lateral wall, exposure of the calcaneocuboid joint, and sufficient area laterally for plate fixation. However extensile approach is associated with increased risk of complications like delayed wound healing, wound dehiscence, infection etc. Soft tissue covering the lateral wall of the calcaneum is supplied by the lateral calcaneal artery which is thin and vulnerable, making the extensile lateral approach prone to wound complications. Risk factors for complications in the wound after calcaneal open reduction and internal fixation include single-layered closure, high body mass index, extended time between injury and surgery, smoking, diabetes, and open fractures. Therefore less extensive approaches were described including the approaches described by Palmer, modified obtuse-angled approach, limited lateral approaches, postero-lateral approach modified lateral Palmer approach, etc Many studies have shown that the clinical results were similar between calcaneal fractures treated with an extensile approach and those treated with a minimally invasive approach.
However, incidence of wound infection and secondary surgeries complications significantly lower in minimally invasive approach.
Sinus tarsi approach permits good visualization of the fracture and allows anatomic reduction of articular surfaces.
In 2008, Hospodar et al studied 16 consecutive cases using minimally invasive sinus tarsi approach. No major wound complications were found in those cases.The posterior facet joint was successfully reduced to less than 2mm of displacement in 14 patients .
On the other hand, Nathaniel et al. report a higher incidence of deep infection in cases treated with sinus tarsi (17.6%). This was not the case in our experience, as we found only 1/34 cases developed deep infection. No specific factor could be attributed to the occurrence of this infection. Sural nerve injury has been reported as complications of sinus tarsi approach. We did not see any such case; the incidence of sural nerve injury increases if the incision extends posterior to the lateral malleolus, and we ensure adequate visualization of the nerve with careful retraction whenever possible. Abdelazeem et al used limited open sinus tarsi approach and fixation by screws only technique to manage 33 cases of DIACFs. Marked improvement in Böhler angle was noticed in all patients. The mean preoperative angle was 2.8°, and postoperatively it was 19.4°. In 2015, Yeo et al. reported successful improvement in Böhler angle from 17.0° to 26.5° using sinus tarsi approach. In Our Study Preoperative Bohler angle ranged from 7.10±23.19° and postoperative 24.16 ± 8.12, Preoperative Gissane angle ranged from 38.8°–105° and postoperative gissane angle 105°-138°. In this study, we achieved sufficient exposure of the posterior facet. There was a significant improvement in Böhler angle from 7.10° to 24.16° and Gissane angle from 38.8° to105°.(P<0.01) .
In our study, satisfactory reduction of the fracture was obtained through limited sinus tarsi approach in all 20 calcaneum cases. Incidence of complications was 1(20 cases) (5%) which is quite less compared to the studies with extensile lateral approach. The results were good with average AOFAS score of 84(86.7 ± 15.9).
In our study, 08 Sanders II, 08 Sanders III, and 4 Sanders IV calcaneal fractures were included in this study population. Most authors only included Sanders II and Sanders III fractures. There are very few studies that included Sanders IV fractures.
The reduction of the posterior facet was graded as nearly anatomical (less than 2 mm articular displacement) in 08 feet (40%) of type II fractures, 08 feet (40%) of type III fractures, and 4 feet (20%) of type IV fractures. Our outcome correlated with the Sanders classification. It has been reported that wound complications ranged from 0% to 5%. In all patients Bohler angle, Gissane’s angles were corrected to normal value with valgus correction which were satisfactory. Good results correlate with restoration of Bohler angle. There is significant correlation between preoperative Bohler angle and the injury severity of the fracture but postoperative Bohler angle parameters have a significant correlation with the functional recovery. We found no difficulty in fracture reduction, and were able to restore both Bohler and Gissane angles to acceptable or better levels from the supportive evidence in the literature, and our experience of 20 cases, we would recommend considering the sinus tarsi approach to be the new gold standard for the treatment of DIACFs.
Complex calcaneal fractures were sufficiently exposed by a sinus tarsi approach for anatomic reduction and stable fixation. Sinus tarsi approach provides good exposure to the talocalcaneal joint. ORIF of calcaneus fractures through sinus tarsi approach allows good exposure with low risk of complications. Despite a limited number of patients, this study suggests that the quality of reduction and stability of internal fixation are satisfactory, supporting the continued use of this technique. Its less invasive method for treatment of calcaneal fractures. It permits good exposure of the fracture, and allows good reduction of articular surfaces. Most patients had good or excellent functional outcome results, through Sinus tarsi approach.
- McLaughlin JR, Lee KR. Total hip arthroplasty with an uncemented femoral component. Excellent results at ten-year follow-up. J Bone Joint Surg Br. 1997 Nov;79(6):900-7.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
- Wang H, Gu J, Liu X et al. Variation in greater trochanteric lateroversion: a risk factor for femoral stem varus in total hip arthroplasty. HIP International. 2020 Jan 1;30(1):33–9. [CrossRef][Google Scholar]
- de Beer J, McKenzie S, Hubmann M, et al. Influence of cementless femoral stems inserted in varus on functional outcome in primary total hip arthroplasty. Can J Surg. 2006 Dec;49(6):407–11. [CrossRef][Google Scholar]
- Min BW, Song KS, Bae KC, et al. The Effect of Stem Alignment on Results of Total Hip Arthroplasty with a Cementless Tapered-Wedge Femoral Component. The Journal of Arthroplasty. 2008 Apr 1;23(3):418-23. [CrossRef][Google Scholar]
- Campbell A, Rorabeck C, Bourne R, et al. Thigh pain after cementless hip arthroplasty. Annoyance or ill omen. The Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery British volume. 1992 Jan;74-B(1):63-6. [CrossRef][Google Scholar]
- Khanuja HS, Vakil JJ, Goddard MS, et al. Cementless femoral fixation in total hip arthroplasty. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2011 Mar 2;93(5):500-9. [CrossRef][Google Scholar]
- Krishnamoorthy VP, Perumal R, Daniel AJ, et al. Accuracy of templating the acetabular cup size in Total Hip Replacement using conventional acetate templates on digital radiographs. J Clin Orthop Trauma. 2015 Dec;6(4):215-9. [CrossRef][Google Scholar]
- Noble PC, Alexander JW, Lindahl LJ, et al. The anatomic basis of femoral component design. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1988 Oct;(235):148-65[CrossRef][Google Scholar].
- Casper DS, Kim GK, Parvizi J, et al. Morphology of the proximal femur differs widely with age and sex: relevance to design and selection of femoral prostheses. J Orthop Res. 2012 Jul;30(7):1162-6. [CrossRef][Google Scholar]
- Clohisy JC, Nunley RM, Carlisle JC, et al. Incidence and Characteristics of Femoral Deformities in the Dysplastic Hip. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2009 Jan;467(1):128-34. [CrossRef][Google Scholar]
- Kienapfel H, Sprey C, Wilke A, et al. Implant fixation by bone ingrowth. J Arthroplasty. 1999 Apr;14(3):355-68. [CrossRef][Google Scholar]